Florida School Principal Who Paddled 6-Year-Old Did Not Commit Crime, Police Say

by : Emily Brown on : 08 May 2021 16:03
Florida School Principal Who Paddled 6-Year-Old Did Not Commit Crime, Police SayWINK News

Police in Florida have determined that a headteacher who hit a six-year-old child with a paddle did not commit a crime. 

Melissa Carter, who works at Central Elementary School in Clewiston, Florida, was caught on camera by the child’s mother as she punished her for damaging a computer.


The incident took place after a school clerk named Cecilia Self called the child’s mother to say the school has a small paddle they could use to smack the child with, but that the mother and a deputy sheriff would have to be present to supervise.

See footage of the incident below. Warning: Distressing Content:

Corporal punishment is still legal in several Florida counties, however it is banned in Hendry, where the incident took place. A police report was filed against Carter and the clerk on April 13, but after reviewing the footage Hendry County Sheriff Steve Whidden said he ‘saw no crime being committed’ from his ‘perspective’.


The sheriff stated that it was up to the state attorney to decide whether to bring charges against the school principal, but a memo from the State Attorney’s Office, cited by Wink News, states, ‘It is clear using a paddle to spank a child is not likely to cause death or great bodily harm.’

The mother is said to have gone to the school to witness the discipline, but was ‘confused’ by a language barrier and ‘did not understand the process correctly’.

Teacher holding paddle used to hit child ( Brent Probinsky/Wink News)Brent Probinsky/Wink News

The mother’s attorney, Brent Probinsky, explained she is an undocumented immigrant in fear of being deported and said, ‘She was confused as to her rights, what she should do… the mother didn’t know if they had a right to paddle her.’


Despite the mother’s confusion, the state attorney said ‘a parent has a right to use corporal punishment to discipline their children, and similarly has the right to consent that others do so on their behalf’.

Carter was placed on administrative leave while the Clewiston Police Department investigated the incident, saying it is ‘working diligently to ensure that the rights of all parties in this matter are preserved’.

Teacher who paddled student (Brent Probinsky/Wink News)Brent Probinsky/Wink News

In a statement cited by The Independent, the police department added that it ‘takes all matters of child welfare seriously and remains committed to protecting the most vulnerable members of our community’.


Due to her uncertainty around the situation, the mother decided to record the scene while hiding the phone with her purse.

Her lawyer said, ‘In my view, this is a crime. This is an aggravated battery. What happened is barbaric, outrageous. Corporal punishment has to end.’

Criminal Defense Attorney Robert Foley has said that since Hendry County District Schools don’t allow punishments of the type seen in the video, the two staff members could still face disciplinary action from the district.

If you have a story you want to tell, send it to UNILAD via [email protected]

Most Read StoriesMost Read


Trump Finally Admits He Didn’t Win The Election

Emily Brown

Emily Brown first began delivering important news stories aged just 13, when she launched her career with a paper round. She graduated with a BA Hons in English Language in the Media from Lancaster University, and went on to become a freelance writer and blogger. Emily contributed to The Sunday Times Travel Magazine and Student Problems before becoming a journalist at UNILAD, where she works on breaking news as well as longer form features.

Topics: News, Florida


The Independent and 1 other
  1. The Independent

    Police clear teacher caught on camera spanking a child with a paddle

  2. Wink News

    State Attorney’s Office: School principal paddling of child is not a crime